Yes. When Josh Hart’s threes are falling, he can decide a playoff game. He proved it in Game 2 of the Eastern Conference finals, scoring 26 points in the New York Knicks’ 109-93 win over the Cleveland Cavaliers and matching his postseason high, according to box scores from Sporting News and Yahoo Sports. His shooting erased concerns after a late-game benching in Game 1 and forced Cleveland to rethink a strategy that had left him open from deep. For fantasy managers and Knicks watchers the immediate rule is simple: Hart matters most when those threes are falling, and coach Mike Brown has shown a willingness to adjust minutes when they're not.

If you are weighing whether to keep Hart in a playoff lineup, start with this: he can decide a game when he is hot. That was the blunt result of Game 2, where Hart’s scoring night helped push the Knicks to a 2-0 series lead and gave New York a decisive third-quarter surge.

How Game 2 played out

Hart finished with 26 points, matching his best postseason output, and played 33 minutes in the 109-93 victory, per Sporting News and Yahoo Sports. The box score line is precise: 10-of-21 from the field, 5-of-11 from three-point range, 1-of-2 from the free throw line, seven assists, four rebounds, two steals, one turnover and five personal fouls. Cleveland repeatedly left him room on the perimeter after he missed early attempts, and after missing his first three threes Hart made five of his final eight to keep New York in control.

The bounce-back mattered because the series began differently for Hart. In Game 1 he was benched down the stretch after a minus-23 rating in 30 minutes, and Landry Shamet replaced him in late-game minutes and hit the tying three late in regulation. Sports Illustrated and other coverage had flagged that benching as the kind of matchup adjustment coach Mike Brown has used with other wing players when their shooting fails to force defenders to close out. Hart accepted the benching publicly, saying he has no ego about being off the floor and describing himself as someone who will "put the success of the team over the success of myself any day," comments republished by the New York Post.

Why Mike Brown still trusts Hart

Brown's postgame assessment after Game 2 was the clearest signal that Hart remains a trusted component of the rotation. The coach compared Hart’s impact to Andre Iguodala for intangibles and versatile, high-IQ defence, saying Hart "does so many little things that don't show up in his box score." Brown argued that because Hart acts as a connector on both ends he must be given more leash than other players, and that type of player is a winner despite occasional metric shortfalls.

Part of the calculus comes down to how the Cavaliers choose to defend him. Coverage of the series emphasised those matchup dynamics. Cleveland experimented with sagging off Hart after his early misses in Game 2, a plan that had worked in Game 1 but backfired when Hart regained his range.

Brown said the Knicks must play fast to exploit cross-matching and transition, and that Hart’s ability to push in transition and create advantages is why the team can afford to give him freer rein at times.

Mastheads

Statistical context helps set expectations. Sporting News’ season summary lists Hart at about 12.0 points, 7.4 rebounds and 4.8 assists per game for the season, with 50.8 percent shooting from the field and 41.3 percent on three-pointers. He is 31 years old, born March 6, 1995, and is in year three of a four-year, $80.9 million contract he signed with the Knicks before the 2024-25 season. Sporting News also noted Hart had a reported salary of roughly $19.5 million for 2025-26, which makes him one of the team’s higher-paid role players.

That salary profile matters because it raises the stakes on lineup decisions. Brown has shown he will trim Hart’s minutes in matchups where Hart’s shooting doesn't force defences to adjust.

When Hart is cold from long range the coach has options, and he has used them. Sporting News and ESPN Stats & Info also pointed to a recent cold stretch on long-range attempts late in the regular season and into the playoffs, a pattern that made Cleveland’s sagging tactic logical before Game 2.

For fantasy managers the practical reading is straightforward. If Hart is hitting threes he is a multi-category contributor who can help in points, assists and even defensive stats. When he is missing, New York is ready to shift minutes to shooters such as Landry Shamet. Two sources of box score detail, Sporting News and Yahoo Sports, reported Hart’s full line from Game 2, and both accounts show the kind of counting stats that move fantasy matchups. For daily moves monitor how Brown deploys Hart specifically in matchups where Cleveland elects to concede perimeter space.

There is also a personal sideshow to his style. Hart has described himself as a feel-based player who's "never a huge analytics guy," remarks reported by the New York Post and by ESPN. That mindset helps explain why Brown values his instincts on the floor even when some metrics look unfavourable. The coach and player agree that Hart’s worth is as much in how he connects plays and spirits the defence as it's in raw shooting percentages.

So where does that leave Hart in the rotation? The answer splits the audience.

If you need steady, predictable shooting from a wing every night, Hart will frustrate you some nights and reward you others. If you value effort, transition creation and the ability to change a game through defence and activity, Hart is a reliable playoff factor whose minutes Brown will protect more often than not.

We should also be clear about the immediate leverage point. The Cavaliers will continue to judge whether leaving Hart open is an acceptable risk. If they keep conceding perimeter space, Hart now has demonstrated he can make them pay. If they clamp down and force him into different roles, Brown has shown he will shift minutes to the shooting specialist who gives the team spacing.

Related Articles

The Knicks lead the Eastern Conference finals 2-0 and need two more wins to reach the NBA Finals. How Brown uses Hart in the next game will be the clearest sign of whether Hart is being treated as a sustained starter or a matchup-dependent rotation piece.

This article was created with AI assistance.